Entropy
Moderators: honeev, Leonid, amiradm, BioTeam
Entropy
This is a simple question about entropy (which is very important concept in understanding life)
I have learned that when molecules split and mole number increases the entropy of the system also increases. It is explained by saying that  when a molecule is splited to smaller molecules it decreases order in the system (they used the example of gas enclosed in a cylinder and their random motion). I don't know what is the measure of disorder, it seems a bit abstract to me. Though I understand that molecules are like packets of atoms; the larger the molecule the greater the orderliness. But it doesn't seem measurable.
But we know that entropy is a measurable physical quantity which is measured using the equation S=Q/T
Can you explain the increase in entropy in the mentioned case using the equation provided?
I have learned that when molecules split and mole number increases the entropy of the system also increases. It is explained by saying that  when a molecule is splited to smaller molecules it decreases order in the system (they used the example of gas enclosed in a cylinder and their random motion). I don't know what is the measure of disorder, it seems a bit abstract to me. Though I understand that molecules are like packets of atoms; the larger the molecule the greater the orderliness. But it doesn't seem measurable.
But we know that entropy is a measurable physical quantity which is measured using the equation S=Q/T
Can you explain the increase in entropy in the mentioned case using the equation provided?

 Garter
 Posts: 1
 Joined: Fri Nov 21, 2008 12:16 pm
 Location: warangal, India
Re: Entropy
Entropy is not disorderliness. It is the measure of how thermal energy can spread or shared into available microstates of the system. It shows in how many ways the thermal energy can be spreaded in the system. It means dilution of thermal energy.
AdiChemistry: An Online Resource of Chemistry
Re: Entropy
Entropy Theory is an extremely wrong one.
Disorderness cannot be measured by entropy. Orderness of system has nothing to do with entropy. Order can be raised in a closed system.
Disorderness cannot be measured by entropy. Orderness of system has nothing to do with entropy. Order can be raised in a closed system.
Re: Entropy
I suggest you read the book was written by Chinese Ecologist Wang Zhaoqiang: Order and Entropy_Scientific Puzzlement of 100 years.
I have read its original Chinese version. However, I don't know whether it was already translated into English. The main idea of the book as follows:
Order is created by order factor, not by fluctuation;
Entropy is a wrong theory. Orderness has nothing to do with entropy.
I have read its original Chinese version. However, I don't know whether it was already translated into English. The main idea of the book as follows:
Order is created by order factor, not by fluctuation;
Entropy is a wrong theory. Orderness has nothing to do with entropy.
Last edited by Alberts on Tue Feb 03, 2009 5:50 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: Entropy
The formula of entropy as follows:
dS=dQ/T
dQ represents changed amount of heat energy in a very very short time;
T represents the temperature of system in a instant;
dS represents changed amount of entropy in that short time.
It is as though changed amount of mass of a glass of water (dm) has nothing to do with height of water (h) in that instant. What about if we construct a new function________
dB=dm/h
Can the function dB make any sense?
So dS as well as S (entropy) have not any meaning.
Therefor the conclusion is : Entropy is a wrong function!
Please do not waste your time with the meaningless function.
dS=dQ/T
dQ represents changed amount of heat energy in a very very short time;
T represents the temperature of system in a instant;
dS represents changed amount of entropy in that short time.
It is as though changed amount of mass of a glass of water (dm) has nothing to do with height of water (h) in that instant. What about if we construct a new function________
dB=dm/h
Can the function dB make any sense?
So dS as well as S (entropy) have not any meaning.
Therefor the conclusion is : Entropy is a wrong function!
Please do not waste your time with the meaningless function.
please do not waste OUR time with meaningless analogies.
You do not understand math and physics: that is your right
You want to show it to the world and make a fool of yourself: I can confirm you just did exactly that.
You want to waste other people time arguing about that: Nope. As a mod i won't let you do that.
You do not understand math and physics: that is your right
You want to show it to the world and make a fool of yourself: I can confirm you just did exactly that.
You want to waste other people time arguing about that: Nope. As a mod i won't let you do that.
Patrick
Science has proof without any certainty. Creationists have certainty without
any proof. (Ashley Montague)
Science has proof without any certainty. Creationists have certainty without
any proof. (Ashley Montague)
Re: Entropy
Any scientific hypothesis and theory should go through rigorous testing and proofing.If the entropy is a correct theory in your opinion, please give me some convincing proof.
Re: Entropy
Entropic world view is a mechanistic world view. It is wrong to use it in biological field.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests