table of contents table of contents

Yeast display provides a system for engineering high-affinity proteins using a fluorescent-labeled …

Home » Biology Articles » Bioengineering » Development of a novel strategy for engineering high-affinity proteins by yeast display » Discussion

- Development of a novel strategy for engineering high-affinity proteins by yeast display

Antibody engineering to facilitate targeting of antigens hasbeen used extensively in the development of antibodies as potentialtherapeutic agents. The most frequent uses of in vitro techniquesseek to optimize antibody binding affinities, typically througha platform such as phage display (Hawkins et al., 1992Go; Markset al., 1992Go). Alternatively, phage display has been used toidentify lead antibodies against targets using either purifiedantigens (Edwards et al., 2003Go) or biopanning procedures employingwhole cells or tissues (Giordano et al., 2001Go; Trepel et al.,2002Go). Like antibodies, TCRs recognize a diverse array of antigens.However, unlike the antigens recognized by antibodies, the antigensrecognized by T cells represent a greater challenge from thebiochemical perspective. These antigens consist of a short peptidethat is non-covalently associated with a cell surface heterodimerencoded by the MHC for class II or the MHC and ß2-microglobulinfor class I. Ternary complexes of peptides and MHC productsexhibit widely diverse stabilities and thus the ability to expressand purify these ligands varies widely. Various laboratories,including the NIH tetramer facility and commercial vendors,provide purified complexes of various well-characterized pMHCligands. However, the variety of MHC alleles (2101 in totalamong human class I and II), and the large number of possiblepeptides makes it difficult to use purified ligands more generally.In order to develop a strategy for engineering TCRs with high-affinityfor a diverse array of antigens, it would be advantageous toavoid the need for purification of the ternary antigen complexes.We show here that it is possible to combine the yeast displaysystem with a rapid density centrifugation method to selecthigh-affinity TCRs. The strategy required only the use of syntheticpeptides that could be loaded exogenously onto an APC that expresseson its surface the proper MHC molecule.

In the examples described here, the density centrifugation methodcan be compared favorably to our previous experience using purifiedpMHC antigens and FACS (Holler et al., 2000Go; Holler et al.,2003Go; Chlewicki et al., 2005Go). In previous studies, three orfour rounds of yeast cell growth, induction and sorting wererequired to identify TCR mutants with high affinity. This processrequired a period of 2–3 weeks, whereas the density centrifugationmethod used here to isolate QL9/Ld or Y5/Ld mutants requiredonly a few hours for selections, through only one or two centrifugations.Thus, this method is rapid, obviates the need for a high-speedflow sorter and does not require purified ligands. While theprecision and ability to perform off-rate based screens remainsan inherent advantage of FACS and yeast display (Boder and Wittrup,1998Go), the present strategy should prove useful for the manysystems that lack purified ligands and for laboratories withlimited access to FACS instrumentation. In a different selectionapproach that also does not require FACS instrumentation, Yeungand Wittrup used biotinylated antigens and streptavidin-coatedmagnetic beads to isolate yeast that express antigen-specificscFvs with an enrichment of ~100-fold (Yeung and Wittrup, 2002Go).While the method described in the present report can be usedonly for ligands that are expressed on cell surfaces, our findingsshow that remarkable enrichments of 1000-fold can be achievedwith only single-pass density centrifugations.

Recent reports have shown that high-affinity TCRs can also beengineered by phage display (Laugel et al., 2005Go; Li et al.,2005Go). It is reasonable to predict that the same type of biopanningthat has been performed with phage-displayed peptides or antibodies(Kupsch et al., 1999Go; Giordano et al., 2001Go; Roovers et al.,2001Go; Trepel et al., 2002Go) could be used for the phage-displayedTCRs, using peptide-loaded APCs. It is possible that this approachmay also find some use in the isolation of ‘lead’pMHC binders from libraries of naïve TCRs, although suchlibraries have not yet been reported. If the density methoddescribed here were to be used with yeast-display librariesof naïve TCRs, clearly the affinities of the TCRs wouldneed to be above a particular threshold (e.g. KD values <1µM). Whether TCRs can be obtained from naive librariesand, if so, whether they retain the typical diagonal dockingorientation on the pMHC ligand (Garcia and Adams, 2005Go) remainsto be determined.

In addition to providing validation that the density centrifugationmethod could be used to isolate high-affinity TCRs from a libraryof mutants, sequence analysis of the panels of high-affinityTCRs against QL9/Ld and Y5/Ld revealed CDR3{alpha} motifs that maycorrelate with recognition differences between these two verysimilar ligands. Accordingly, all mutants isolated against QL9,which contains a Phe at position 5, represented a CDR3{alpha} motifwith a key glycine at residue 101{alpha}. In contrast the additionof a hydroxyl group in the Y5 peptide variant appears to allowthe isolation of CDR3{alpha} mutants with more diversity in their CDR3{alpha}.The molecular explanations for these differences remain to beresolved and will require structural studies of the TCR-peptide/Ldcomplexes. Nevertheless, the data point to the exquisite peptidefine-specificity that is associated with the recognition ofpMHC ligands by TCRs.

As indicated, many pMHC ligands of interest have not yet beensuccessfully expressed and purified in soluble form. This limitationis particularly pronounced for class II MHC ligands (Hackettand Sharma, 2002Go), and, despite significant advances in classII MHC multimer technology, there are still relatively few classII MHC multimers available (Cameron et al., 2002Go). While theexpression of class I MHC molecules in E. coli has been standardizedfor many alleles, it has been more difficult to develop standardizedprotocols for class II MHC production and only a few MHC classII molecules have be produced in E. coli. Some class II MHCmolecules have been successfully isolated following secretionfrom insect cells, often as fusion products with introducedleucine zipper domains to assist in chain association (Scottet al., 1996Go). One fundamental difference between class I andclass II MHC involves the chaperones that facilitate foldingand peptide loading intracellularly (Cresswell and Lanzavecchia,2001Go). Our method of exogenous peptide loading completely eliminatesthe need to develop expression and purification protocols foreach peptide-class II MHC multimer. For example, such an approachmay be useful in the discovery of high-affinity TCRs that bindto class II MHC antigens that are involved in autoimmunity (Lebowitzet al., 1999Go; Masteller et al., 2003Go).

Finally, it is conceivable that this methodology could be extendedto other receptor–ligand interactions, as well as to theengineering of high-affinity antibodies against tumor antigens(Boder and Wittrup, 2000Go; Feldhaus et al., 2003Go; van den Beucken,2003Go; Hoogenboom, 2005Go). In fact, an alternative biopanningstrategy using an antibody–hapten model system was publishedduring the preparation of this manuscript (Wang and Shusta,2005Go). These studies monitored recovery of yeast expressinga high-affinity, fluorescein-specific antibody from a fluorescein-labeled,adherent endothelial cell monolayer. While this approach islimited to adherent cell lines and has yet to be applied toselections from combinatorial libraries, it provides furtherevidence of the potential of yeast display in cell-panning strategies.Furthermore, mammalian proteins other than antibodies or TCRshave been expressed on the cell surface via the yeast displaysystem (Bhatia et al., 2003Go; Schweickhardt et al., 2003Go). Forexample, the cell adhesion molecule E-selectin, which helpsinitiate extravasation of leukocytes by binding sialyl-Lewis-xligand on the leukocyte cell surface, has been expressed asa functional construct on the surface of yeast (Bhatia et al.,2003Go). As the use of yeast display expands as a tool for directedevolution, the density centrifugation strategy for selectionsmay serve to support broadened efforts in library screening,especially when purified soluble selecting agents are not available.


rating: 4.00 from 2 votes | updated on: 10 Oct 2008 | views: 17272 |

Rate article: