Login

|
|
Anything can evolve into anything.Moderator: BioTeam
3 posts • Page 1 of 1
Anything can evolve into anything.Anything can evolve into anything.
The statement sounds laughable, but it's worth recognizing that in principal it is a true statement. Pick any two organisms on the evolutionary tree of life (ancestral or modern), and there were always be transitional forms leading from one to the other. Dawkins explains this in the first chapter of The Extended Phenotype:
Just something interesting I thought I'd point out. Your comments/criticisms are welcome.
Re:
Your point is? In fact, no, please do not answer, your fantasy are neither informative, interested, or based in anything that look like science. So please STFU. In response to the OP, I guess the lecturer has a point, one can imagine that it is theoretically possible. However, when on start to imagine the number of gene replications, duplication, loss and acquisition by horizontal genetic transfer that would be necessary, and the odds associated to get a specific (set of) gene in response to a given selective pressure, the possibility is quite microscopic. As S.J. Gould pointed in one of his essays, if there was a way to rewind the story of life to replay it, the outcome would be radically different each and every time. There is often more than one "good" reaction to a given evolutionary pressure, and the one(s) that prevails are not necessarily the best in an absolute way, just the one that were lucky enough to be selected for. And I think that Dawkins' tutor hypothetical case is not much more than just mental masturbation, without much significance in term of evolutionary biology. Patrick
Science has proof without any certainty. Creationists have certainty without any proof. (Ashley Montague)
3 posts • Page 1 of 1
Who is onlineUsers browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests |
© Biology-Online.org. All Rights Reserved. Register | Login | About Us | Contact Us | Link to Us | Disclaimer & Privacy