Natural selection is proven wrong

[jumma]

there is nothing like "starting mutation". Mutation simply happens and that's it

tart the

then you have point 2 of deans

the generation of new species

1) if the process is random then genetics cannot account for why a species appears for being random there can be no deterministic reason why it happens in a particular why- once the generation process has started genetics can account for how it unfolds-but genetics cannot account for its random starting point chaos theory might but genetics cant

2)if there is some plan programmed into the genes/DNA such that species unfold according to the plan
then
genetics cant account for the generation of new species- it can account for how the process might unfold
but
it cant account why the genes have been progammed that way- the idea of god might but genetics can

but for point 1
something needs to get to the gene to start the mutation ie virus radiation etc
so tell us the random process that gets the something ie virus radiation etc to the gene

[OdinsRaven]

Why aren't any of you talking about the sun?

It was there before any life on this planet began. You asked why mutations started in the first place. How about the idea that mutations are a tool for adaptation. The sun changes, the weather changes, gravitational forces change, atmospheric content changes, there are many changes. It seems that DNA is also subject to change. Actually it seems that everything is subject to change. Is that not what a mutation is, just a change.

Without change, there is extinction.

The real question is why does life matter so much to keep it going? Changes happen, we know how they happen and even in many cases where they originated from, but whats the point of this continuous adaptation through generations of lifeforms?

[jumma]

The sun changes, the weather changes, gravitational forces change, atmospheric content changes, there are many changes

now that is some sort of explanation behind the random process that starts the mutation that leads to the generation of a new species

that is a lot more than canalon has offered - but then he want find explanations like that in his holy/sacred biology text books
all canalons books can tell us is what happen AFTER the starting process not BEFORE

[JackBean]

The sun changes, the weather changes, gravitational forces change, atmospheric content changes, there are many changes

now that is some sort of explanation behind the random process that starts the mutation that leads to the generation of a new species

This is explanation??? So what did we provide?

[jumma]

The sun changes, the weather changes, gravitational forces change, atmospheric content changes, there are many changes

you say

This is explanation??? So what did we provide?

GEEEEEEEE

The sun changes, the weather changes, gravitational forces change, atmospheric content changes, there are many changes

all those changes could/can be part of the random process that start mutations that generate new species

ie a virus was blown onto a gene
sun spots might have caused a lonely neutron to fly onto a gene
chemicals in the atmosphere might have fallen onto a gene
etc
etc

that is a lot more than canalon has offered - but then he want find explanations like that in his holy/sacred biology text books
all canalons books can tell us is what happen AFTER the starting process not BEFORE

[canalon]

A mutation is a change in the genetic code. It does not start before the DNA is changed by chemical or other means. You do not make sense.
In fact the more you are trying to argue the more you are showing your complete ignorance of the subject at hand. I gave you a link to a place where you can go and instruct you for free. You chose instead to make a fool of yourself. Do not expect to be treated with any sort of respect. You deserved to be called an ignorant idiot, and you will be, you ignorant idiot.

[jumma]

A mutation is a change in the genetic code

a changed caused by ie a virus radiation via a random process a random process genetics cant explain
an example of such a random process which could start the mutation

The sun changes, the weather changes, gravitational forces change, atmospheric content changes, there are many changes



all those changes could/can be part of the random process that start mutations that generate new species

ie a virus was blown onto a gene
sun spots might have caused a lonely neutron to fly onto a gene
chemicals in the atmosphere might have fallen onto a gene
etc
etc

[david23]

"a virus was blown onto a gene" something is terribly odd with this statement

same with "sun spots might have caused a lonely neutron to fly onto a gene" well this one is just wrong. Neutrons cant move so freely without some kind of catastrophic effect

"chemicals in the atmosphere might have fallen onto a gene" why not, sounds pretty "ok"