Design and testing of low intensity laser biostimulator
Emil S Valchinov and Nicolas E Pallikarakis
Department of Medical Physics, University of Patras, Patras 26500, Greece
BioMedical Engineering OnLine 2005,
4:5doi:10.1186/1475-925X-4-5. [Open Access article]
Abstract
Background
The non-invasive nature of laser biostimulation has made lasers an
attractive alternative in Medical Acupuncture at the last 25 years.
However, there is still an uncertainty as to whether they work or their
effect is just placebo. Although a plethora of scientific papers
published about the topic showing positive clinical results, there is
still a lack of objective scientific proofs about the biostimulation
effect of lasers in Medical Acupuncture. The objective of this work was
to design and build a low cost portable laser device for stimulation of
acupuncture points, considered here as small localized biosources
(SLB), without stimulating any sensory nerves via shock or heat and to
find out a suitable method for objectively evaluating its stimulating
effect. The design is aimed for studying SLB potentials provoked by
laser stimulus, in search for objective proofs of the biostimulation
effect of lasers used in Medical Acupuncture.
Methods
The proposed biostimulator features two operational modes: program
mode and stimulation mode and two output polarization modes: linearly
and circularly polarized laser emission. In program mode, different
user-defined stimulation protocols can be created and memorized. The
laser output can be either continuous or pulse modulated. Each
stimulation session consists of a pre-defined number of successive
continuous or square pulse modulated sequences of laser emission. The
variable parameters of the laser output are: average output power,
pulse width, pulse period, and continuous or pulsed sequence duration
and repetition period. In stimulation mode the stimulus is
automatically applied according to the pre-programmed protocol. The
laser source is 30 mW AlGaInP laser diode with an emission wavelength
of 685 nm, driven by a highly integrated driver. The optical system
designed for beam collimation and polarization change uses single
collimating lens with large numerical aperture, linear polarizer and a
quarter-wave retardation plate. The proposed method for testing the
device efficiency employs a biofeedback from the subject by recording
the biopotentials evoked by the laser stimulus at related distant SLB
sites. Therefore measuring of SLB biopotentials caused by the stimulus
would indicate that a biopotential has been evoked at the irradiated
site and has propagated to the measurement sites, rather than being
caused by local changes of the electrical skin conductivity.
Results
A prototype device was built according to the proposed design using
relatively inexpensive and commercially available components. The laser
output can be pulse modulated from 0.1 to 1000 Hz with a duty factor
from 10 to 90 %. The average output power density can be adjusted in
the range 24 – 480 mW/cm2, where the total irradiation is limited to 2
Joule per stimulation session. The device is controlled by an 8-bit
RISC Flash microcontroller with internal RAM and EEPROM memory, which
allows for a wide range of different stimulation protocols to be
implemented and memorized. The integrated laser diode driver with its
onboard light power control loop provides safe and consistent laser
modulation. The prototype was tested on the right Tri-Heater (TH)
acupuncture meridian according to the proposed method. Laser evoked
potentials were recorded from most of the easily accessible SLB along
the meridian under study. They appear like periodical spikes with a
repetition rate from 0.05 to 10 Hz and amplitude range 0.1 – 1 mV.
Conclusion
The prototype's specifications were found to be better or comparable
to those of other existing devices. It features low component count,
small size and low power consumption. Because of the low power levels
used the possibility of sensory nerve stimulation via the phenomenon of
shock or heat is excluded. Thus senseless optical stimulation is
achieved. The optical system presented offers simple and cost effective
way for beam collimation and polarization change. The novel method
proposed for testing the device efficiency allows for objectively
recording of SLB potentials evoked by laser stimulus. Based on the
biopotential records obtained with this method, a scientifically based
conclusion can be drawn about the effectiveness of the commercially
available devices for low-level laser therapy used in Medical
Acupuncture. The prototype tests showed that with the biostimulator
presented, SLB could be effectively stimulated at low power levels.
However more studies are needed to derive a general conclusion about
the SLB biostimulation mechanism of lasers and their most effective
power and optical settings.